Proforma invoice vs. commercial invoice: when to use each
A proforma invoice and a commercial invoice look similar on screen, which is why shipping teams sometimes attach the wrong one to an outbound pallet. In international trade, they happen at opposite ends of the order lifecycle.
1. Key differences at a glance
| Feature | Proforma Invoice | Commercial Invoice |
|---|---|---|
| When issued | Before packing or production (quote / offer stage) | After packing, when actual goods are ready to ship |
| Purpose | Buyer approval, wire prepayment, letter of credit, import license application | Customs valuation, duty assessment, forwarder SLI & carrier handoff |
| Quantities & weights | Estimated order quantities and estimated weights | Exact shipped quantities, carton counts, net weight and gross weight matching the packing list |
| Validity date | Usually includes an offer expiration date | Finalized transaction document with invoice number and date |
| Customs clearance (commercial sale) | Generally rejected by customs for commercial entries | Standard customs invoice required at destination |
2. Why sending a proforma at shipping causes customs holds
Between the day a buyer accepts a proforma quote and the day the warehouse seals the pallets, real-world changes happen: two units back-order, a mixed carton splits into two boxes, or pallet tare weight changes gross weight. If logistics forwards the unedited proforma instead of a checked commercial invoice reconciled against packed cartons, the invoice disagrees with the packing list and Bill of Lading.
3. Clean workflow from quote to export shipment
- Send a clearly labeled Proforma Invoice (with Incoterms® 2020 + named place, currency and validity date) when the buyer requests a quote or import permit document.
- Once the warehouse packs the cartons, record actual packed quantities, carton ranges and net/gross weights.
- Run a pre-shipment check (try the 24-carton discrepancy checker) so the finalized Commercial Invoice, Packing List, Carton Labels and SLI match 1:1. Need a quick single invoice? Generate a commercial invoice PDF free.
Frequently asked questions
Does a proforma invoice count against Packlistly’s monthly shipment allowance? No. Creating a proforma invoice PDF in Packlistly does not consume your monthly shipment quota.
When do brokers ever ask for a proforma invoice at customs? Rarely for commercial sales; occasionally for non-sale free samples, warranty replacements or temporary exhibitions where local customs rules specify a valuation invoice—always confirm with the destination customs broker first.
General information, not legal, accounting or customs advice. Confirm destination customs invoice requirements with your customs broker.